Ranking tables
Clinical Negligence | UK Bar
Scotland (Bar)
Rankings overview for Sets
Senior Statespeople
- Colin MacAulay KCArnot Manderson
Star Individuals
- Maria Maguire KCAmpersand Advocates
Band 1
- Andrew Smith KCCompass Chambers
- Astrid Smart KCCompass Chambers
- Euan Mackenzie KCAmpersand Advocates
- Iain Ferguson KCAxiom Advocates
- Lauren Sutherland KCAmpersand Advocates
- Lisa Henderson KCAmpersand Advocates
- Roddy Dunlop KCAxiom Advocates
- Simon Bowie KCAmpersand Advocates
- Una Doherty KCAmpersand Advocates
Band 2
- Alastair Duncan KCAxiom Advocates
- Amber Galbraith KCCompass Chambers
- Calum H S MacNeill KCWestwater Advocates
- Geoffrey Mitchell KCAmpersand Advocates
- Graham Primrose KCAmpersand Advocates
- Isla Davie KCAmpersand Advocates
- Jamie Dawson KCAmpersand Advocates
- Kay Springham KCCompass Chambers
- Neil Mackenzie KCArnot Manderson
- Richard Pugh KCCompass Chambers
- Robert Milligan KCCompass Chambers
- Vinit Khurana KCAmpersand Advocates
New Silks
- Fiona Drysdale KC Ampersand Advocates12 Years Ranked
- Chris Paterson KCAxiom Advocates
- Helen Watts KCAxiom Advocates
- James McConnell KCAmpersand Advocates
- Malcolm McGregor KCCompass Chambers
- Paul Reid KCAmpersand Advocates
Band 1
- Arabella TaitArnot Manderson
- Mark FitzpatrickAmpersand Advocates
Band 2
- Ewen CampbellAxiom Advocates
- Jennifer Nicholson-WhiteAmpersand Advocates
- Kate BennettCompass Chambers
- Nick GardinerArnot Manderson
- Philip StuartAmpersand Advocates
- Yvonne WaughCompass Chambers
Band 3
- Barney RossCompass Chambers
- David SwanneyCompass Chambers
- Robin ClelandCompass Chambers
- Shane DundasAmpersand Advocates
Up and Coming
- Bruce LanglandsCompass Chambers
All Sets profiles
Band 1
1 Ampersand AdvocatesClinical Negligence2025 | Band 1 | 14 Years RankedAmpersand Advocates "has huge experience in dealing with highly complex cases" and retains its reputation as a "go-to chambers for medical negligence work." Its advocates continue to provide expert legal advice and representation to both pursuers and defenders in a wide range of disputes, including claims relating to birth and catastrophic brain and spinal injuries. Its members are well versed in cases arising from alleged failures in diagnosis and surgical errors, and regularly appear at fatal accident inquiries. The stable also houses considerable expertise in obstetric negligence cases. Ampersand's members recently acted in McCulloch v Forth Valley Health Board, which re-examined the law on reasonable treatment options and was heard before the UK Supreme Court.
Band 2
2 Axiom AdvocatesClinical Negligence2025 | Band 2 | 11 Years RankedAxiom Advocates has a growing team with capabilities in representing both claimants and defendants and offering "excellent attention to detail and sound legal expertise." Members have expertise in handling matters regarding cerebral palsy, obstetric injury, cauda equina and failure to diagnose, with additional expertise in matters regarding cancer, and quantum and liability issues. The stable is regularly sought to represent hospitals, GP practices, dentists, health boards and medical defence unions. Recently, members assisted a private individual in a claim against a dentist who had reused single-use dental equipment, which caused psychiatric injury in the claimant.