Chambers Review
Provided by Chambers
Clinical Negligence - Scotland (Bar)
What the Team is Known For
Arnot Manderson is a stable well known for complex medical negligence matters. Its members are regularly called upon to represent both pursuer and defender clients, including NHS hospital trusts, medical defence organisations and individual doctors and dentists, in high-value catastrophic or fatal injury claims. In addition to offering expertise in injuries arising from negligence and delayed or failed diagnosis, the stable's advocates are also well regarded for their handling of claims involving defective medical products and equipment. Recent cases saw members acting for the family of a former psychiatric patient who took their own life, and acting for the claimant in a case of failure to diagnose a retinal detachment resulting in permanent eyesight damage.
Andrew Sutherland leads the clerking team as practice manager.
Notable practitioners
Colin MacAulay KC is a venerable silk with a longstanding reputation in the clinical negligence space. He concentrates on litigating catastrophic injury claims and also serves in public inquiries.
Arabella Tait is an esteemed advocate who is recognised for her assured handling of a diverse array of clinical negligence cases. She is instructed by both defender and pursuer clients and has accrued impressive experience in relation to catastrophic injury claims, including delayed diagnoses, surgical failures and wrongful birth matters. She is also well regarded for her expertise in dental negligence claims.
Arabella is excellent in grasping and explaining the most complex of cases. She is a very experienced advocate and a strong negotiator.
Neil Mackenzie KC is an acclaimed silk with an extensive civil practice. He is instructed by both defenders and pursuers in high-value clinical negligence claims. He possesses notable experience in handling obstetric cases and surgical error claims.
Neil is an experienced and knowledgeable senior counsel who is very approachable, and able to explain complex legal issues to clients in a clear and accessible way.
Nick Gardiner is a noteworthy advocate who has developed an extensive practice in personal injury as well as medical negligence cases, acting for both pursuers and defenders. He often receives praise for his thoroughness and attention to detail. Gardiner is an experienced and well-equipped advocate able to handle failed diagnoses and birth injuries.
Nick is great. He is so calm under pressure, so detailed with his analysis and unafraid to pick up the phone. He is very proactive and will work with you to find a solution to a problem.