Department profile
Calfee, Halter & Griswold LLP

Insurance: Policyholder

USA Guide 2026 : Ohio


Calfee, Halter & Griswold LLP

Rankings

About

Provided by Calfee, Halter & Griswold LLP

Calfee’s Insurance Coverage group serves corporate insurance policyholder clients on all aspects of insurance coverage legal needs. 

Our Insurance Recovery lawyers help clients identify insurance assets to provide coverage, develop and present coverage claims to insurance companies, negotiate resolutions to insurance coverage disputes, and litigate against insurance companies in court and alternative dispute resolution forums.

  • Help public, closely held, and private equity clients secure and negotiate representations and warranties insurance to protect M&A deal values.
  • Counsel clients’ risk management teams and work with brokers on insurance procurement and renewals and help clients maximize the scope of coverage through customized endorsements to standard policy forms. 
  • Counsel clients and work with brokers to evaluate and negotiate specialized policy enhancements, i.e., cyber, directors’ and officers’ (D&O), fiduciary, and employment practices liability (EPL) policies.
  • Help clients identify insurable losses, provide effective notice and claim submissions to insurers, address reservations of rights and denials issued by insurers, and negotiate the resolution of coverage disputes with insurers.
  • Prosecute and defend insurance coverage lawsuits in state and federal trial and appellate courts nationwide and in arbitration and mediation.
  • Guide clients on issues involving large self-insured retentions, deductibles, retrospective premium arrangements and captive insurance programs. 

Industries (16)

  • Aviation
  • Banking, Financial Services and Insurance
  • Chemicals
  • Construction
  • Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPS)
  • Entertainment, Media and the Arts
  • Entrepreneurs and Emerging Companies
  • Government
  • Health Care
  • Individuals and Families
  • Medical Devices, Pharmaceuticals and Life Sciences
  • Partnerships, LLCs and Joint Ventures
  • Private and Family-Owned Businesses
  • Private Equity
  • Public Companies
  • Retail and Consumer Products

Chambers Review

Provided by Chambers

Insurance: Policyholder - Ohio

Band 1

Band 1


What the Team is Known For
Calfee Halter & Griswold boasts an impressive reputation with decades of experience in policyholder insurance representation. The firm is well known for its capabilities in risk mitigation and cost recovery strategies. It provides representation in all aspects of insurance coverage policy disputes, including those surrounding M&A transactions. It has an impressive roster of clients that include those in the academic, healthcare and manufacturing sectors.

Work Highlights

Provided by Chambers

  • Calfee, Halter & Griswold continued to advise The Ohio State University in sexual misconduct claims made by former male-student athletes against Dr. Richard Strauss, a former doctor employed by the university during the 1970s-1990s.

Strengths

Provided by Chambers

  • Calfee’s insurance recovery practice stands out in the industry for its rare combination of technical mastery, strategic creativity, and deep client focus.

    Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA
  • They answer the bell every time, and do so in a way that marries legal risk with the business realities our company faces.

    Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA
  • Calfee's expertise in insurance recovery is absolutely compelling. They handle complex matters with ease and the sort of strategic focus that one would hope to be commonplace, but which is not.

    Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA
  • The team is excellent at understanding the context of the issues from both a business and legal framework, communicating our options clearly and drilling down on the details.

    Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA

Notable Practitioners

Provided by Chambers

  • Band 1James Sullivan
    Band 1James Sullivan

    James Sullivan

    James Sullivan is held in high esteem for his approach to complex recovery claims, which sees him handle a wide range of coverage disputes.
    • James is distinguished by his great critical analysis, responsiveness and outside-the-box thinking.

      Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA
    • James is a top-notch lawyer.

      Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA
    • As head of Calfee’s Insurance Recovery practice, he combines first-rate oral advocacy skills with a humble, gracious demeanor that puts clients and colleagues at ease.

      Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA
    • He is responsive, eager to help, knows his stuff.

      Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA
  • Band 2Matthew Chiricosta
    Band 2Matthew Chiricosta

    Matthew Chiricosta

    Matthew Chiricosta has a good reputation due to his in-depth experience providing insurance coverage and litigation counseling to clients. He regularly advises clients from a wide range of industries including education, healthcare and manufacturing.

    • He is the rare attorney who has a combination of technical expertise, strategic acumen, and client-first approach.

      Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA
    • Matt is an exceptional attorney with deep expertise in insurance recovery and a strong grasp of commercial realities. He is thoughtful, strategic, and consistently delivers high-quality advice tailored to our business needs.

      Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA
    • He is very talented.

      Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA
  • Band 3Jodi Spencer
    Band 3Jodi Spencer

    Jodi Spencer

    Jodi Spencer Johnson has extensive experience advising corporate and individual policyholders in a range of insurance coverage issues.

    • Jodi's work and guidance was timely and informative.

      Insurance: Policyholder respondentUSA
  • Band 3Matthew Mendoza
    Band 3Matthew Mendoza

    Matthew Mendoza

    Matthew Mendoza is a go-to for complex insurance coverage matters.

Ranked Individuals at Calfee, Halter & Griswold LLP (4)

Ohio

Members

Provided by Calfee, Halter & Griswold LLP

What success is built on

Chambers is the leading data and intelligence partner for the legal sector.

Explore thought leadership