INDONESIA: An Introduction to FinTech Legal
Fintech 101 : Indonesia
With the continued rapid growth of technology, new financial technologies are also being invented. The Indonesian government has been reforming its licensing regulations to cater for this invention while also protecting local interests. This article will briefly discuss those fintech activities that are regulated (and recognised) in Indonesia.
Securities crowdfunding
On 11 December 2020, Indonesia’s financial services authority, Otoritas Jasa Keuangan (OJK), enacted OJK regulation No 57 on securities crowdfunding (POJK 57), revoking a previous regulation of 2018 on equity crowdfunding. POJK 57 was later also amended by OJK regulation No 16/POJK.04/2021, which requires the crowdfunding operator to be registered with the Ministry of Communications and Information Technology. In general, POJK 57 expands the scope of crowdfunding to include equity securities in shares and other types of securities, such as debt securities and sukuk, or other convertible equity.
Significantly, POJK 57 now allows Indonesian non-legal entities – as opposed to only Indonesian limited liability companies in the 2018 regulation – to participate as issuers. It brings an opportunity for small and medium-sized enterprises and start-ups to acquire a new source of income.
Even though the equity crowdfunding business seems promising, unfortunately, only a few platform providers have obtained OJK approval to legally operate the crowdfunding activities. From the market’s perspective, it is understood that there are some hurdles for business players in developing crowdfunding businesses. Some of the big issues are that:
– obtaining the licence from OJK is not easy for most platform providers due to the perquisite requirements; and
– most of the custodians are not ready to take part/operate in the equity crowdfunding scheme.
Peer-to-peer (P2P) lending
The country’s P2P business was previously covered in OJK regulation No 77 on information technology-based lending (POJK 77) which had been the underlying regulation for P2P business in Indonesia since 2016. POJK 77 was finally revoked and replaced by OJK regulation No 10 on 4 July 2022 (POJK 10). Due to the abuse of P2P business by the operators, the Indonesian government has tightened P2P regulations in POJK 10 to protect the public’s interests. POJK 10 adopts the regulations of the existing OJK regulations in other heavily regulated business sectors such as insurance, securities, and multi-finance, among others the fit and proper test requirement for the controlling shareholders and the board members. This regulation sets the scope of the P2P lending practice, from its business activities, registration and licensing procedures, the relationship between the P2P lending providers and users, risk mitigation, information technology system maintenance, to prohibitions on P2P lending and the minimum requirements concerning agreements between the lender-borrower and lender-service provider. POJK 10 also introduces the concept of a Sharia principle for the P2P business activities. Recently, the OJK issued a circular letter which adds more governance rules for P2P operators in Indonesia. The most notable regulation concerns the limitation of the maximum rate of interest that can be received by the operators, including the interest and administration fee. The circular letter sets a maximum interest rate of (i) 0.1% per day over the loan amount for productive financing, which would be applicable by 1 January 2024 (this rate would be reduced to be 0.067% by 1 January 2026); and (ii) 0.3% per day over the loan amount for consumptive financing, which would be effective by 1 January 2024 (this rate would be reduced to be 0.2% by 1 January 2025 and 0.1% by 1 January 2026). We believe this regulation has been added to address the issue of overly high interest rates that are charged to P2P borrower. In addition, the circular also sets some regulations concerning debt collection and the borrowers can only have active lending arrangements with a maximum of three P2P operators.
Payment system
On 29 December 2020, the central bank, Bank Indonesia, issued a Bank Indonesia regulation, Peraturan Bank Indonesia (PBI) No 22 on payment systems (PBI 22), which is effective from 1 July 2021. Bank Indonesia explained that the reform is intended to change the payment system regulatory framework from an institutional approach to an activity and risk-based approach. Under PBI 22, payment system providers are classified into two categories:
– Payment services providers, or penyedia jasa pembayaran (PJP) – these are banks or non-bank institutions that offer services in facilitating payment transactions to users such as account information services, payment initiation and/or acquiring services, account issuance services, and/or remittance services. A PJP company must obtain a license from Bank Indonesia.
– Payment system infrastructure providers, or penyelenggara infrastruktur sistem pembayaran (PIP) – these are parties that provide infrastructure for transferring funds and carry out clearing and/or final settlement. A PIP company must obtain a so-called appointment from Bank Indonesia.
PBI 22 also introduces foreign direct investment restrictions. PJP business is open to 85% foreign shareholding, provided that at least 51% of shares with voting rights, management control and veto rights are held by Indonesian shareholders. PIP business is only open to 20% foreign shareholding, provided that at least 80% of shares with voting rights, management control and veto rights are held by Indonesian shareholders. The calculation of the shareholding participation will be traced up to the ultimate beneficiary of the shareholders.
Crypto-assets
Crypto-assets have been acknowledged as a commodity in Indonesia since 2018 through the issuance of Ministry of Trade regulation No 99 of 2018 on General Policy on Crypto-asset Trading. As a follow up to this, the Commodity Futures Trading Regulatory Agency (Bappebti) issued a regulation in 2019 to regulate the trading mechanism for crypto-assets, namely Bappebti regulation 5/2019 that was most recently amended by Bappebti regulation No 13 of 2022 (Reg 13).
Crypto-assets’ characteristics under Indonesian law
Under Indonesian law, crypto-assets are categorised as a commodity that can be traded in the market. However, crypto-assets cannot be used as a method of payment in Indonesia. The prevailing laws and regulations in Indonesia only permit the use of the Indonesian rupiah as a currency and method of payment for transactions that are effected within the territory of the Republic of Indonesia.
Crypto-assets can only be traded in the physical market if the crypto-assets are approved by and registered with Bappebti. Bappebti recently updated the list of crypto-assets that are approved for trading on the local crypto-assets market. With the updates, there are now 383 approved crypto-assets to be traded in Indonesia. Some of the notable new entries in the lists are Secret (SCRT), Axie Infinity (AXS), Ethereum Name Service (ENS), PancakeSwap (CAKE).
Key market players
The key players in the physical crypto-asset futures that are regulated under Reg 13 are, among others, crypto-asset exchanges, crypto-asset clearing agencies, crypto-asset traders, crypto-asset clients, and crypto-asset storage providers. To be appointed as a crypto-asset exchange, crypto-asset clearing agency, crypto-asset trader, crypto-asset client, or crypto-asset storage provider, each party must fulfil certain Bappebti requirements, including minimum issued and paid up capital, equity maintenance, employing employees with certain certifications, and passing the fit and proper test requirement (for the members of the board of directors, board of commissioners, shareholders, and controller/beneficial owner).
Tax obligations
The Indonesian government imposes VAT and income tax on crypto-assets transactions, as regulated under Minister of Finance (MoF) regulation No 68/PMK.03/2022.
I) VAT
The MoF will impose VAT on the following categories:
– Intangible taxable goods in the form of crypto-assets activity, this includes (i) sale and purchase of crypto-assets with fiat money, swap of crypto assets, and/or (iii) swap of crypto assets with other goods and/or services.
– Taxable services in the form of the provision of electronic facilities for crypto-assets trading by the trade organiser through the electronic system (PPMSE). This includes the provision of services for (i) sale and purchase of crypto-assets with fiat money, (ii) swap of crypto-assets, (iii) e-wallet services for the deposit, withdrawal, transfer of one crypto-asset to the other party’s account and the management of the media for the storage of the crypto-assets.
– Taxable services in the form of verification of crypto-assets transactions and/or management services of the mining pool of crypto assets by the mining pool.
II) Income Tax
Any income received by (i) crypto-assets traders, (ii) trade organisers through the electronic system, or (iii) crypto miners in relation to the crypto-assets will be subject to income tax. The income of the crypto-assets traders will be subject to final income tax with the tariff of 0.1% of the transaction amount (if the electronic system that is used for the transaction is registered with Bappebti), or 0.2% of the transaction amount (if the electronic system that is used for the transaction is not registered with Bappebti).
The latest development concerning crypto-asset regulation in Indonesia concerns the change of supervising authority. Crypto-assets were previously under the authority of Bappebti but were repositioned to fall within the control of the OJK. It is expected that the full transfer will be achieved by 2025 – thus, further amendments to the regulations are expected under the OJK.
Digital gold
Trading of digital gold in Indonesia was first legalised through the issuance of Minister of Trade regulation No 119 of 2019. The trading process was further regulated by Bappebti through Bappebti regulation No 4 of 2019 on Technical Provisions on Implementation of a Digital Gold Physical Market in Futures Exchange as amended by Bappebti regulation No 13 of 2019 (Reg 4). Reg 4 requires a digital gold trader to fulfil certain requirements, including (i) being a member of a licensed futures exchange and a clearing house and (ii) placing the physical gold in a designated gold storage manager.
The digital gold transactions that are allowed to be conducted according to Reg 4 are sale and/or purchase, buy as you like until the specified grammation of the gold can be printed for collection, fixed instalments with later delivery, entrusted, printing of gold, and other transactions according to innovations, developments and needs in digital gold trading.
Mutual funds
In Indonesia, a mutual fund in the form of collective investment fund or KIK Mutual Fund can only be offered and sold to investors by an investment manager. This is regulated under OJK regulation No 23/POJK.04/2016 as amended by OJK regulation No 2/POJK.04/2020 on Mutual Funds in the Form of Collective Investment Contracts (POJK 23). Nevertheless, the POJK 23 opens an opportunity for investment managers to co-operate with other parties who have (i) wide networks in their business activities (to provide point of sales or sales outlets), and/or (ii) a credible electronic system.
To adapt to the fast-paced technology, the regulation also provides that the transaction of a mutual fund participation unit can be conducted electronically, either through an electronic system built by the investment managers themselves or through co-operation with a third party.
Digital banking
To survive the competition against fast-paced fintech rivals and keep up with the changing lifestyles of their customers, banks are required to adapt and provide better services, especially in connection to IT. Thus, banks need to develop business models to include digital banking, enabling their customers to conduct their banking activities online. To accommodate this, the OJK has issued a guideline for conducting digital banking by conventional banks. The guideline allows banks to open digital branches where the customers can perform self-service banking activities. To open these digital branches, the banks will first need to add the digital branches to their submitted business plans to the OJK, meet the required capital thresholds, obtain the approval of the OJK, and ensure the security of their electronic systems to support the digital branches. The regulation concerning digital banking is also regulated under the P2SK Law.
IT-based advisory services
The IT-based advisory services sector (“automated advisory”) is regulated in Bappebti regulation No 12 of 2022 (Reg 12). Automated advisory can monitor the market, calculate market entry or exit opportunities, place reasonable transactions and perform risk management by considering each of the client’s needs. It may look similar to the illegal robot trading that has previously been shut down by Bappebti but this is different as that illegal robot trading does the actual trading for the customers, not only providing advice. On the other hand, automated advisory, as regulated in Reg 12, is only one of the tools to be used by customers in making a decision. That decision and the responsibility for it would be solely in the hand of the customers.
Automated advisory can only be provided by licensed futures advisors (FA) that have obtained Bappebti approval to carry out the automated advisory in their service. The FA can apply for the licence online through the Bappebti website. FA applicants must comply with a number of requirements, including (i) a positive recommendation from a futures exchange in respect of the application, system or programme they propose to operate; and (ii) additional issued and paid-up capital of at least IDR1 billion (USD67,000), on top of the existing requirement of net assets worth a minimum of IDR500 million, per Bappebti regulation No 6 of 2020.
While the new regulation states that an FA may be an individual person or a legal entity, it is unclear whether individual FAs will actually be capable of obtaining licences from Bappebti due to the minimum capital requirement, which can obviously only be applied to a corporate FA.
The FA must assess the knowledge of the customers, the customers’ financial ability, the customer’s risk profile, risk appetite and risk objective before promoting automated advisory to their clients. Further, the FA are prohibited from (i) promising that the use of the automated advisory will bring a stable profit or be risk-free, (ii) doing the transaction on behalf of the customer, (iii) promoting profit-sharing to the customer, or (iv) carrying out multi-level marketing schemes to promote the automated advisory. Last, the FA must enter into an advisory agreement with their customers to perform the automated advisory, which clearly states that the FA would not be responsible for any risks and losses that may occur to the customers from the trading activity. However, Reg 12 states that notwithstanding this statement, the FA must be responsible if the Bappebti finds that they were responsible for conduct that violates regulatory obligations in performing the automated advisory, or if there is non-compliance of the feature of the program/application, as required by Reg 12.
Law on Development and Strengthening of the Financial Sector
The Indonesian government has been reforming many laws and regulations since 2020 in an attempt to attract more investors. The latest amendment was on the financial sector by the issuance of Law No 4 of 2023 (P2SK Law). In addition to the change of supervising authority for crypto-asset activities, there are a few regulations concerning financial technology that are regulated under the P2SK Law.
Digital currency
Bullion
The P2SK Law also introduces the concept of bullion activities, which are related to the deposit, financing, trading, and safekeeping of gold. These activities will fall under the supervision of the OJK. The P2SK Law has not provided extensive regulations concerning these activities. It is also expected that further regulations will be regulated in the implementing regulations.
Financial sector technology innovation (ITSK)
The P2SK defines ITSK as technology-based innovation that impacts products, activities, services and business models in the digital financial ecosystem. ITSK includes payment systems, settlement of securities transactions, risk management, market support, and activities related to digital financial assets, including crypto-assets. The P2SK Law stipulates that a party, unlicensed for Indonesia, that operates ITSK activities, is liable to five to ten years’ imprisonment and fines of up to IDR1 trillion (approximately USD64 million). These sanctions are aimed at shutting down the operation of unlicensed (illegal) financial technology companies.
Unregulated fintech activities
As a result of constant innovation in the financial technology sector, some fintech business models are not yet covered by the existing regulations. To deal with this problem, the Indonesian government employs sandboxing and digital innovation regulations.
For fintech related to the payments system, Bank Indonesia regulation No 23/6/PBI/2021 on Payment Services Providers allows Bank Indonesia to determine that a particular product, activity, service, or business model may be “sandboxed” for testing purposes. The purpose of this is to (i) encourage technological innovation and (ii) monitor/detect opportunities and risks of technological innovation, the development of the digital economic and financial ecosystem, and the implementation of the payment system.
For fintech related to lending and all other aspects of fintech, OJK regulation No 13/POJK.02/2018 of 2018 on Digital Financial Innovation in the Financial Services Sector establishes a digital financial innovation (DFI) regime that consists of three separate aspects – ie, recordation, regulatory sandbox, and registration. Initially, the prospective DFI providers should be recorded with the OJK as the DFI providers. Once the provider has been recorded, the OJK will review whether it is qualified to participate in the regulatory sandbox process. After completing the sandbox process, the OJK will issue a recommendation status. If the provider receives a recommendation for registration, it must apply for registration to the OJK within six months of the issuance of the recommendation.
Commentary
In general, the Indonesian government has caught up with the development of fintech business models by issuing regulations for the relevant fintech activities in Indonesia. The government even tries to “regulate” unregulated business models through the sandbox mechanism. In addition, the government has established an Investment Alert Task Force according to the Decree of the Head of BAPEPAM-LK No Kep-208/BL/2007, dated 20 June 2007 (the “Task Force”). It is a co-ordination forum between the regulators, supervisory agencies, law enforcement agencies and other related parties for the handling of allegedly unlawful acts in the field of public fundraising and investment management. Although the duties and authorities of the task force are not expressly regulated by specific legislation, we note that the members of the task force (eg, the OJK, Bappebti, and MCIT) have successfully closed and blocked several un-registered offshore and onshore websites that were allegedly carrying out business unlawfully with Indonesian customers, gathering public funds, and potentially endangering the public. These include peer to peer lenders, unlicensed robot trading services, binary options trading platforms, and investment offers with money game schemes. In early 2022, the Bappebti closed the operation of some companies that offered robot trading services to Indonesian customers. The so-called robot trading companies offer automated trading services for commodities (either forex, crypto or gold). The Bappebti closed the services of these companies because they were unlicensed, leading to many customers losing access to their funds and accounts.
The issuance of Reg 12 may also be an answer to combating unlicensed robot trading activities in Indonesia. The scheme envisaged by Bappebti under Reg 12 differs from old-style robot trading in a fundamental way: erstwhile robot trading companies operated directly on the customer’s behalf, frequently made unrealistic promises on profitability, and were promoted through multi-level marketing schemes. Crucially, they did not meaningfully assess the actual preparedness or capacity of customers for high-stakes, automated commodities trading. This is now all outlawed by Reg 12, which attempts to ensure more responsible use of the opportunities presented by technology and greater protection for retail investors by requiring the licensing of futures advisors and greater selectivity when accepting customers. Above all, Reg 12 makes it crystal clear that full-blown robot trading is now prohibited in Indonesia.
About the firm:
