10 Aug 2017

In Atlantisrealm Ltd v Intelligent Land Investments (Renewable Energy) Ltd one privileged document (out of 7,389 reviewed) was inadvertently disclosed to the Claimant’s solicitors by a trainee solicitor. This is a common occurrence in large scale electronic disclosure exercises, as Lord Justice Jackson commented in this Judgment.

The assistant solicitor at the Claimant’s firm who initially reviewed the privileged email gave evidence, which was accepted by the Court of Appeal, that he did not recognise that it had been disclosed in error. The senior partner of the firm, who saw the email at a later date, also put forward evidence that he did not recognise that there had been a mistake.

On 19 July 2017, the Court of Appeal rejected the senior partner’s evidence and held that he must have been aware that there had been a mistake.

Lord Justice Jackson said:

“If the inspecting solicitor does not spot the mistake but refers the document to a more percipient colleague who does spot the mistake before use is made of the document, then the court may grant relief. That becomes a case of obvious mistake.”

Lord Justice Jackson also noted that while the privileged email “was not fatal” to the defendant’s case, it had provided “useful ammunition.”

Stephen Hornsby, a Partner at Goodman Derrick comments:

“The Judgment (unlike the decision in the Leeds High Court) is a real victory for common sense for which the legal profession will be grateful, as it advances the law in a way which assists litigants who are concerned to minimise the costs of litigation.”

About Goodman Derrick

Goodman Derrick LLP is a commercial law firm in the City of London. The firm is recognised for providing high quality legal advice across a range of practice areas and for its distinctive, client-focused service.
•30 partners leading a team of over 90
•A recognised adviser to FTSE-listed, national and international businesses, including many household names
•Recommended as a leading law firm in key practices by the independent guides to the legal profession, Chambers & Partners and Legal 500
•A founder member of Legal Netlink Alliance, please see the international section of our website for more information (www.gdlaw.co.uk)
•Founded in 1954 by Lord Goodman and established as a limited liability partnership in 2006


Antonia Welch, Welch PR

[email protected]

Tel: 07813 917980

James Caulfield, Goodman Derrick

[email protected]

Tel: 07815 846124

[1] The privileged email was one of a total of 4,891 documents disclosed to the claimant’s solicitor.