Managing employment relationships requires careful attention to employee wellbeing and compliance with employment laws. Fundamentally, employers in the UK must balance business needs with the legal and ethical responsibilities they hold toward their workforce.
Mental health is an increasingly important area in this context, and understanding the implications of terminating an employee with mental health issues is crucial. Employers must ensure that any decision to end an employment contract is fair, reasonable and compliant with legislation such as Employment Rights Act 1996 and the Equality Act 2010.
Under the Equality Act, mental health conditions such as depression, anxiety, and bipolar disorder may qualify as disabilities, depending on their severity and impact on daily life. Employers are required to make reasonable adjustments to support employees with such conditions. Failure to do so could result in claims of discrimination or unfair dismissal.
Before considering termination, employers should take proactive steps to address concerns. Where an individual has been off work due to mental health issues, conducting a return to work interview can provide a structured opportunity for open dialogue with the employee. These interviews help employers understand the reasons for absence, discuss any adjustments that could support the employee in their role, and agree on a plan for their return. Such conversations should be handled with empathy and confidentiality to foster trust and ensure the employee feels supported.
Absence management is another area of risk. A common question arises: how many sick days before disciplinary action is appropriate? There is no set number of days that automatically triggers disciplinary action, as each case must be assessed individually. Employers should consider the nature of the employee’s illness, whether it is linked to a mental health condition, and the impact of their absence on the organisation.
Clear policies on sickness absence, shared with employees from the outset, can help set expectations and provide a framework for addressing issues fairly.
Employers may also explore alternative working arrangements, such as hybrid working, or more fundamental changes to support employees experiencing mental health difficulties. For example, annualised hours allow flexibility by spreading an employee’s working hours over the year, which can accommodate fluctuations in their ability to work. Similarly, a fixed term contract may provide a temporary solution, giving both the employer and employee time to assess whether the arrangement meets their needs. These options can demonstrate a commitment to supporting employees while maintaining business continuity.
In some cases, employers may explore the possibility of redeployment or adjustments to the employee’s role. This demonstrates a commitment to supporting the individual and can mitigate the risk of legal disputes. If termination becomes unavoidable, it is vital to follow a fair process. Employers should document all steps taken, including discussions, adjustments, and any occupational health assessments. This evidence can protect against claims of unfair treatment and demonstrate that the decision was not taken lightly.
Positive discrimination is another aspect that employers may encounter when managing workplace diversity and inclusion. Unlike other forms of discrimination, positive discrimination involves giving preferential treatment to individuals with protected characteristics, such as mental health conditions, to address imbalances in the workplace. While positive discrimination is generally not permitted under UK law, certain measures, such as positive action, are allowed. Positive action enables employers to provide additional support or training to underrepresented groups without breaching legal boundaries. Employers should ensure that any initiatives in this area are carefully designed to comply with the law and promote equality.
Promoting mental health awareness and creating a supportive workplace culture can help employers reduce the likelihood of disputes related to mental health issues. Training managers to recognise signs of mental health difficulties and equipping them with the skills to provide appropriate support is an effective way to achieve this. Employees who feel valued and understood are more likely to remain engaged and productive, benefiting both the individual and the organisation.
In conclusion, handling employment matters involving mental health requires sensitivity, knowledge of the law and a commitment to supporting employees. Conducting a return to work interview, addressing questions about sick leave and disciplinary action, and understanding the legal implications of terminating an employee with mental health issues are all important steps. Employers should also consider the role of positive action in fostering an inclusive workplace.
Contact our experts for professional advice on dealing with workforce management issues, or with any employment law or UK immigration issues affecting your organisation such as: